DIY Moving vs. Hiring NYC Movers: Which Is Better?
Select Page

DIY Moving vs. Hiring NYC Movers: Which Is Better?

It doesn’t matter if you’re moving across town or across the country; the moving process is expensive and stressful. Even in the best-case scenario, it can take at least a month to organize and plan your move, and that doesn’t even include the packing! The biggest question you might have when moving to NYC is whether hiring professional movers is right for you. After all, it allows you to offload the stress of lifting and transporting. In fact, many NYC moving companies also offer partial and full packing services.

Of course, all of this comes at a price. For many people, the DIY route might seem attractive as it’s the cheaper option. However, it might not always be the best choice for you. So, how do you know when to hire a mover? Below are a few variables you should consider when deciding to hire NYC movers.

Managing Your Time Effectively

The first thing you should consider is how much time you have to complete your move. There are a lot of reasons why you might be short on time for your move. Maybe you were too busy with work, or perhaps you broke off a long-term relationship and need to move out immediately. Whatever the reason, if you’re on a tight time schedule, it might make sense to hire movers to take care of the time-consuming work of packing and moving your stuff.

 

Average Moving Time Comparison

Move Type DIY Time (Hours) Pro Movers Time (Hours) Main Time-Saver
Studio 8–10 3–5 Fast loading/unloading
1 Bedroom 12–14 4–6 Coordinated crew
2 Bedroom 15–18 6–8 Equipment + expertise
3 Bedroom 18–22 8–10 Additional movers
Long-Distance 30+ 10–15 Logistics & routing

*Estimates are based on average NYC moving conditions and may vary depending on building access, distance, and amount of furniture.*

 

If you’re moving with other people, you should be completely transparent with each other about how much time they can dedicate to the move. Even if you plan and organize everything perfectly, things don’t always go as expected, and you might end up running behind schedule. If you or roommates/family members have doubts about the amount of time they need to get everything packed and ready, hiring movers might be a good choice.

Smart Budgeting Strategies

Money and time are just as important when deciding if movers are worth it for your relocation. Before you start calling up your local movers, you need to figure out how much money you can put aside. In order to do so, you first need to get a general idea of how much movers cost. Of course, this depends on a variety of factors such as distance, how much you need to move, additional services, and more. In general, a local NYC move can cost between $500-800 for a studio apartment for your standard loading and unloading. Once you start adding other services such as packing/unpacking, moving supplies, tips for movers, etc., and more, the price can get close to $1,000.

To get the most accurate quote from a moving company, take an inventory of your home and figure out what you actually plan on bringing with you. This process can also help you decide if you need movers or if you can do it yourself. An inventory can also help in case items get lost or damaged, and can also help obtain renters’ insurance or homeowner’s insurance for your new place.

 

Average Moving Costs in NYC (2025)

Apartment Size DIY Cost Estimate Pro Mover Cost Estimate Notes / Assumptions
Studio $250 – $400 $500 – $800 Light furniture, minimal items
1 Bedroom $350 – $600 $800 – $1,200 Standard moving, not heavy bulk
2 Bedroom $500 – $800 $1,200 – $1,800 More furniture, more boxes
3 Bedroom $700 – $1,200 $1,800 – $2,800 Includes large items (sofa, beds, etc.)
4+ Bedroom / Large Home $1,000+ $2,800 – $4,000+ Big load, many movers & bigger truck

*These are ballpark estimates for NYC moves in 2025. Actual costs can vary based on distance, building restrictions, additional services, packing needs, and access constraints (stairs, elevator, walk-up, etc.).*

 

Once you have tallied all your items, call up at least 3 to 4 different moving companies so you can look at the average price. This can give you a general idea of what you can expect. Make sure to include the cost of any additional services you want to add. On the other hand, if you’re budget is tight you can choose to DIY some aspects of the move, such as packing yourself or finding ways to get moving supplies for free or cheap. You might even go the DIY move route if you only have to move a handful of boxes and no heavy furniture or equipment.

Physical Ability

Be honest with yourself. When was the last time you lugged around a bulky piece of furniture up and down a flight of stairs? Chances are, you’ve only done it once when you moved into your apartment. A DIY move might be cheaper initially, but what happens if you hurt yourself during the move? If you’re not familiar with proper lifting techniques, you can easily throw out your back, which means you might have to hold off on your move for at least a few days. Even if you manage to rope in a few friends, moving furniture and other items is hard work. Plus, what happens if someone else gets hurt helping you move?

Experienced movers have moved pretty much every type of furniture and appliance possible. They are also specifically trained in appropriate moving and safety procedures to ensure no one gets hurt on the job. And they use specialized moving equipment to make their work safer and faster. Plus, if they end up damaging the building you’re moving out of or into, they will have insurance to cover the damages.

Considering the Distance in Your Move

While hiring professional movers is great even if you’re moving down the street, you definitely will want to hire them if you’re making a long-distance move. While the basic steps are the same, packing and loading into a vehicle come with their own set of challenges. For example, you can’t make multiple trips if everything doesn’t fit in one vehicle, and you can’t depend on friends or family to help you unload at your new place. Depending on how far you’re moving, it might even take several days for you to reach your final destination.

 

Long-Distance Move Logistics

Destination City Distance (Miles) Estimated Drive Time Typical Moving Cost Notes / Challenges
Philadelphia, PA ~95 mi ≈ 2 hrs $1,000 – $1,400 Short-haul; fewer overnight stops
Boston, MA ~215 mi ≈ 4 hrs $1,400 – $1,900 Traffic critical; tolls major cost
Washington, D.C. ~225 mi ≈ 4.5 hrs $1,500 – $2,000 Border & state line fees; packing tight
Miami, FL ~1,280 mi ≈ 18-20 hrs $3,000 – $5,000 Multiple overnight stops; climate concerns
Los Angeles, CA ~2,800 mi ≈ 40-45 hrs $6,000 – $8,500 Fuel, lodging for crew, interstate fees

*Estimates assume standard household size (2-3 bedrooms), no extreme bulky furniture, and normal road/traffic conditions. Prices may vary depending on full or partial packing, specialty items, and seasonal demand.*

 

It takes a lot of time, effort, and planning to make a long-distance move possible. So, unless your possessions can fit into a few bags and suitcases, you’re better off hiring professional movers. They know exactly how to pack your items on the truck to maximize space and reduce damage. Plus, they will know what routes to take and how to drive safely during bad weather.

In Conclusion: Final Thoughts

By taking all of these variables into account, you can decide whether it makes sense to hire a professional NYC moving service. In some cases, you might have to hire movers, as many newer buildings will require it in order to protect the building from potential damage. So before you decide you can do it yourself, make sure to call your new apartment’s building managers and ask about the moving requirements.

Once you’re ready to make your move, make sure to give us a call to receive a free quote. Great Movers NYC offers amazing quality service at affordable prices. It’s why we’re the movers NYC residents trust.

FAQ

How much should I tip the moving crew?

The typical recommendation is to tip your moving crew around 5% to 10% of the total moving cost, adjusting based on the quality of service, complexity of the move, and your satisfaction. Consider factors like challenging conditions or the number of movers, and feel free to ask the moving company for specific guidelines.

Will NYC movers assemble and disassemble my furniture?

Yes, many professional movers in NYC offer furniture assembly and disassembly as part of their services. However, it's crucial to confirm this with your specific moving company beforehand. Some movers may include this service in their standard package, while others might charge an additional fee for it. Before hiring a moving company, inquire about their policies regarding furniture assembly and disassembly to ensure that your expectations align with the services they provide.

Will it cost more if I’m moving into or out of a walk-up?

Moving into or out of a walk-up may incur additional costs due to the extra effort and time involved. It's advisable to check with your moving company for specific pricing details related to walk-up situations.

Hire NYC Local Movers Now!

Give us a call  and we’ll give you a free estimate for your local NYC move. We’re sure you’ll be happy with our service and we have the reviews to back us up!

Instant Cost Quote

(718) 569-7124

Available online: 2 moving consultants

Our Customer Ratings

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

based on 2,035 reviews

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

based on 147 votes

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

based on 97 reviews

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

based on 168 reviews

Get free quote within minutes

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
SMS consent

All Moving Tips and Tricks

Latest Posts

Related Posts

truck

Get Your Movers Now!